UPDATE:
I have not looked deeper into the carburetor, and have put several hundred more miles on the car since this initial post. Most of those miles had the consistent surging a cruise speeds and I just sort of learned to live with it. But this past Sunday the car suddenly got far worse. This time on the lower end of the speed. It started bogging down severely while trying to accelerate. It has had a little hesitation or stumble, but giving it a little more throttle had made it respond. But on Sunday, I had all I could do to get the thing home. I really had to feather and jab the throttle to keep it running.
I had good confidence in all the shorter runs I was making for a big one that I need to make in the next week or two as I am moving from Chambersburg, PA to Cleveland, OH and its a 275 mile trip for the Thunderbird. I have lost the confidence needed to drive the car in its present condition, but need to make this trip.
So, yesterday, I went out and purchased a vacuum gauge and timing light. I need a lesson in the correct order of tests, but this is what I did:
1. Disconnected the vacuum line to the distributor and plugged the hole in the carb where it was attached.
2. Started the car and let it fully warm up to operating temp
3. Checked the RPMS (via the timing light) and they were about 850-900 in neutral.
4. Checked the timing and if I did this correctly it was 55 degrees advanced at idle without vacuum advance!
I've never used a digital timing light before so I'll explain what I did:
Hooked up the light and could not see the timing mark on the damper at all. There are two buttons on the light marked advance. I pressed one of them until the timing mark lined up with the pointer on the block. The timing light was showing 55 degrees!
I thought I have read here that initial timing should be about 18 degrees. So, I loosened the distributor and turned it counter clockwise until I could get the timing light to register 18 degrees with the timing marks aligned.
The idle dropped substantially so I upped the idle speed back to around 900. I then shut the car off to see how it would restart. It started fine. I then took it for a very short trial to see if this improved things. It was drizzling, the top was down so it was a very short run. It still has the slight hesitation when starting out, couldn't drive at cruising speeds to see if it was still surging, but the severe bogging and cutting out at low speeds was no longer evident on this short run.
I'm assuming (a stretch) that I did the timing correctly. If so how could this have had 55 degrees of initial advance?
Have I done something wrong to get this reading? I have not yet attached the vacuum gauge, nor have I opened the distributor or looked at the plugs. And as mentioned above, I have not touched the carburetor yet.
I suspect I might be starting in the middle when I should start at the beginning looking for my problem. Could you guys suggest a sequence I should use to troubleshoot this issue? I'm under a bit of a gun to move this car either this upcoming weekend or very latest next weekend.
Specs:
'57 312
'57 Ford Distributor with/tach drive
Holley 84057-5 / 1786 carb. Looks to be a 600 CFM aftermarket carb built 178th day of a year ending in 6
Ford O Matic 2-speed automatic
Sorry to be so long winded and thanks, in advance for some needed help.
pops (AKA) Clay'56 Thunderbird