charliemccraney (5/2/2007)
Thanks Ted.
I notice that most trays are curved and some are not. Is there any benefit of one design over another? Because of the deep skirted design, I am thinking that a curved tray is not necessary - or at least not much of a curve will be required. The old airhead BMW motorcycles use flat windage trays. Does the distance between the tray and rotating assembly affect how well the tray functions?
How much clearance is required between a crank scraper and the rotating parts? Does a scraper function better on one side of the block than the other.
To add to John’s comments: the crankshaft counterweights and rods still swing below the lower pan rails so if building a full sized windage tray, some curvature will still be required to clear these items. The design of a full width windage tray is two fold. First is for it to direct the oil back to the pan instead of back into the crankcase area and next is to keep any windage created in the crankcase area away from the sump. A good design will facilitate oil returning to the sump and/or inhibit oil in the sump being pulled back up into the crankcase. If using the windage screen material supplied by the pan manufacturers, this material is directional so it’s important to note the direction it’s installed.
Ideally, the windage tray needs to be a close as possible to the rotating assembly minimize windage and facilitate additional oil removal. Placing the windage tray further away from the rotating assembly just gives more oil the potential of being pulled back up into the crankcase area.
As John said, if building an oil wiper or scraper into package, then that needs to be on the passenger side of the block. If installed on the oil filter side, it will inhibit oil from actually returning back to the pan or sump. Clearance will be dictated by personal preference but definitely needs to be far enough away that actual metal contact will not take place.
Here are pics of a stock 428CJ windage tray and a main support girdle for a Y that incorporates built in windage and oil wiper control. The Y main support that’s pictured is generic in that it doesn’t require any trimming or fitting with up to a 3.44” stroke.


Lorena, Texas (South of Waco)