Autopsy


http://forums.y-blocksforever.com/Topic7173.aspx
Print Topic | Close Window

By Hoosier Hurricane - 17 Years Ago
Bird 55:

In answer to your question of what broke in the Hurricane, I have this to offer.  The last couple of days I have been working on it.  I found #5 rod broken off both sides where the heads of the rod bolts seat.  Arp bolts didn't break.  #5 piston is destroyed, and the cylinder wall cracked.  #1 rod and piston are damaged.  There is about a 3 square inch hole in the side of the block.  It broke out between two of the pan bolts, the pan flange and side are not damaged.  The scraper is demolished, the screen damaged.  The oil pickup tube is OK.  The cam was not touched.  The crank passed magnaflux, will need grinding to remove the nicks and burrs.  The other six rods passed magnaflux.  The six remaining pistons show no signs of cracks in the oil ring groove where the TRW pistons tend to crack.  So other than a little scuffing up of the parts, the engine is not bad.  Bearings and cylinder walls look good.  It's built Ford Tough!

John 

By Ted - 17 Years Ago
John.  Thanks for the detail on the teardown.  And Amen on the Ford tough.  It hurt when I had heard that you had broke the engine but glad it’s not a loss.  Sounds like you’re going to be back up and running without as much work as you had originally figured.  Just give a shout if there’s something I may have on my end that you’ll need to get that ride back up and running
By Moz - 17 Years Ago
g'day john

sorry to hear about the hurricane but after reading your post its good to see she will live to fight another day they sure are one tough engine only ford could build them.

By Ol Ford Guy - 17 Years Ago
John,

How will you repair the hole down low in the block?  Will you have to sleave the cracked cylinder or just a clean it up? or rebore all of the cylinders?  Would it be easier and more economical to start with a new bare block?  Did oil splash out of the hole when you drove it onto your hauler?  Where did it let go, like at the start, middle or near the end of your run.  I guess you have plenty of time to get it repaired.  It sounds like most of your engine components survived and will live to race again.

By Hoosier Hurricane - 17 Years Ago
Guys:

Thanks for the words of support.  I have not decided which way I'll go yet.  Cheap way would be to replace two pistons and rods, and start with another block.  I have several, blocks are not a problem.  Paul, if I were to repair that block, I would get a piece of side from another block, fit and weld it in.  Then sleeve #5, leave the rest of the bores as is.  But as I said, I have more blocks.  I even have a 312 block that a friend gave me, standard bore.  Would be easier to use, wouldn't have to align bore the mains.  Why oh why didn't I listen to everyone else and grind the crank to 292 main bearing sizes???  Then it would bolt into another 292 block.  Ted, I have thought about aftermarket rods, but the ones readily available are made for the 4.6 and are shorter than Y rods.  Does anyone have them in 292 length.  I personally like longer rods.  I should probably go to light pistons, I have TRW anchors now.  I figure the rod let go at the top of the exaust stroke when it has to jerk the piston down when it wants to keep going up.  Paul, it broke at about the 1/8 mile mark, just after I had wound to 6200 and shifted to 3rd.  A little oil splashed out when I loaded it.  I'm surprised I didn't fog the last 1/8 mile of the track, but I'm glad I didn't.  There was no rod on the front throw, so the oil hole was spraying oil at an uncontrolled rate.  Lost a little more when I ran it from the truck to the garage, about 300 yards.

John

By Ted - 17 Years Ago
Hoosier Hurricane (9/13/2007)
Ted, I have thought about aftermarket rods, but the ones readily available are made for the 4.6 and are shorter than Y rods.  Does anyone have them in 292 length.  I personally like longer rods.  I should probably go to light pistons, I have TRW anchors now.

John.  Looking through the Eagle literature, I see a 6.657” long H-Beam rod for the 5.4L V8 and 6.8L V-10 engines.  Definitely long enough and maybe too long depending on what your plan of attack is going to be.  Going back to the 2.100” journal selections, a 6.300” long rod is available which is about as close to the 292 length as it gets but would require rebushing the pin end to the .912 size if you’re sticking with the Ford pins.  If you go the custom piston route, then rod selection doesn’t get as picky and you get the lighter pistons.  As an FYI, the rods in my roadster engine are 6.550" long.

By speedpro56 - 17 Years Ago
John, I'm using Eagle rods in my stroker 312 and they are the 3D H-beam (6.250 " Wink Chester said they were A LOT better than the original rods or the HD Truck rods I had planned on using. Jerry Christenson put me on to these several years ago. The only thing I didn"t like about them was the price. There ph: 901-345-5886 and there in Memphis Tn. if you're interested. Sorry about the bad luck on such a great engine. But knowing you the next engine will be even better. BigGrin
By Hoosier Hurricane - 17 Years Ago
Ted and Gary:

Thanks for the leads.  I like the looks of the 6.300 x 2.100 rod, regardless of which piston I ultimately choose.  John M has said the TRW heavyweights I have are NLA now.  The 6.25 rods are too short to use with my existing pistons at this point, the piston tops have been shaved.  I assume the pin size is sbc size, which is only .015 bigger than the Y.  Would be no problem to hone the pistons to fit the sbc pin size.  How about bottom end widths of these rods?  I need to assess my options, and decide if I need to build a super engine at this stage in my life.  I'm looking at my 67th birthday approaching, wonder how much longer I'll be physically able to keep racing.  And my widow will not know nor care what is inside the engine when she sells off the cars.  Not being morbid, just being realistic.

John

By Bigwin56F100 - 17 Years Ago
When youre gone I'll care! maybe I'll want something great! Build it so it will last me untill I'm 67 (only 38 now)

One tip of advice, remember that preventative maintenance is important as you know for an engine but dont forget about yourself. Dont use the old idea that if its not broke dont fix it. My dad died of prostate cancer at the young age of 71. He had not been to the doctor since 1954 when he was discharged from the army. This goes for all the old timers! I dont want to be the only one in columbus!

Kevin Bigwin

     

Hoosier Hurricane (9/14/2007)
Ted and Gary:

Thanks for the leads.  I like the looks of the 6.300 x 2.100 rod, regardless of which piston I ultimately choose.  John M has said the TRW heavyweights I have are NLA now.  The 6.25 rods are too short to use with my existing pistons at this point, the piston tops have been shaved.  I assume the pin size is sbc size, which is only .015 bigger than the Y.  Would be no problem to hone the pistons to fit the sbc pin size.  How about bottom end widths of these rods?  I need to assess my options, and decide if I need to build a super engine at this stage in my life.  I'm looking at my 67th birthday approaching, wonder how much longer I'll be physically able to keep racing.  And my widow will not know nor care what is inside the engine when she sells off the cars.  Not being morbid, just being realistic.

John

By Hoosier Hurricane - 17 Years Ago
Kevin:

Thanks for the advice.  I have to say I see my doctor at least 4 times a year for checkups and blood work.  He tries to keep me coming back, I figure he has a boat or airplane payment due every 3 months.

John

By MoonShadow - 17 Years Ago
Gee, I only go to the VA once a year to get my new bag of drugs! You must have a real Doctor! I bet he even speaks english?

Anyway, sorry about the engine loss but now is the chance to come back even stronger (as I'm sure you will). My Vicky is running great now, for about 5 miles with smoke pouring out of the oil fill before it locks up and has too cool down. Oh well another Chuck year at Colombus.Tongue

By pintoplumber - 17 Years Ago
Boy, that's something Kevin should mention that today. My oldest brother died of that today, he was 69. I guess he ignored the symptoms.
By Hoosier Hurricane - 17 Years Ago
Dennis and Kevin:

My condolences on the loss of your brother and father.  Funny, we all have to face these things sometime, we know it, yet when it happens we are never ready.  May they rest in peace.

John

By MoonShadow - 17 Years Ago
Sorry to hear about your Father and Brother. Its a tough loss.

Have you had your PSA checked? They recommend annual checks after 50 now. The earlier they test the younger they are finding it.

Thanks to early detection, I went through the prostate thing back in 1997. Detected at 54 years old. Thanks to agent orange! I had the surgery and have had 0 PSA's ever since. It will stop you in your tracks when you realize how quickly you can be gone.

Actually as an aside to all you Y's Guys, ask your doctor about a PSA test if you havent had one! Its curable if found early! Chuck

By Ted - 17 Years Ago

Condolences to all for your losses.  Seems to take place more often as We get older but doesn’t get any easier either.

 

John:

The SBC and 4.6 mod motor rods are wider and simply have to be machined to the smaller width to fit the Y journal.  I’ve tried to widen the journals on the 1.889 journal size to fit the SBC rod width and hit the oil holes in the journal filet on the 292 steel cranks so I can say that combination doesn’t work.  Widening the journals on the 2.100 journal size might be doable but haven’t tried that combination.

 

Thanks for the additional information regarding Winona.  And additional thanks for the story on Bill Smith.  Finicky is good as that’s what typically separates the special from the ordinary.  Sounds like Bill has been busy enough not to worry about the little things like charging for the extras he puts into his work.  Might possibly explain why He’s still at it and busy after 35 years.
By Hoosier Hurricane - 17 Years Ago
Ted:

Yes, Bill keeps busy.  A few years ago he sold his cylinder head equipment to another friend of mine who is not in the machine shop business.  He uses it mostly for his own use on his drag car.  Bill now concentrates on short block building, does a lot of circle track engines.  Sort of the same deal, he built a sprint car engine for another of our friends and it ran away from the field first time out.  Soon most of the field was bringing in engines.

John

By Eddie Paskey - 17 Years Ago
Good Mornin' all;   Sept. 22, we will have our 7th annual Cruisin For a Cure-- largest 1 day car show in US.  Last year had over 3300 cars to see.  All proceeds go to Prostate cancer research.  They bring in a Semi Truck to give PSA test all day long.  We have about 125 surviors that did not kmow they had cancer until they had the test at the show!!  Started by Debbie Baker, because her husband Jim had prostate cancer and is a Hot Rodder, so she put together the show.  If you live close to Orange County, Cal,  COME ON DOWN!!    Have worked the show last 4 years, not this year. because of hip replacements,   Beautiful cars--Lots of venders--- and a free PSA test---   Can't Beat it!!

Look up web  Cruising For a Cure.   Many Thanks----God Bless     Eddie