Steel vs. Cast bellhousing


http://forums.y-blocksforever.com/Topic137506.aspx
Print Topic | Close Window

By Rono - 7 Years Ago
Okay, I was planning on using my T-5 for the blown stroker motor for my 37 coupe. Problem is the T-5 is only good for about 300 HP and I know this motor will put out more than this. A local company showed up at a car show over the weekend called Modern Driveline (MDL) http://www.moderndriveline.com/ they make a super duty T-5 good to 450 HP and also TKO 5 and 6 speed units. They make an adapter plate for the Y Blocks and also a steel bellhousing. Instead of sending off my T-5 to "G-Force Transmission for a rebuild with their gears and main shaft, I thought I'd be better off  with a Super Duty T-5 from MDL and one of their adapter plates to use on my Cast bellhousing. However, MDL is recommending that I go with a steel bellhousing due to the "rotational Force" being put out with the kind of HP I will be making. I had not considered this issue before and aside from the high cost of the bell housing I'm afraid there will be differences in the dimensions between the cast and steel bellhousings that will cause issues with my rear tranny cross member and drive shaft length. So, do you think I need to go with a steel bellhousing for this set-up?
By charliemccraney - 7 Years Ago
Probably not needed.  Lot's of powerful Y-blocks at the nationals with no fancy bellhousings and of all the failures there have been, a bellhousing is not one I know about.

The Y is from a time when things were still pretty over built.  The bellhousings are iron and pretty stout.  My '88 Firebird on the other hand has an aluminum bellhousing that seems paper thin by comparison.  So were it for my Firebird, I'd be concerned but for a Y, not really.

The bellhousing they sell is a Quick Time.  There have been issues with those, one of those products where they seem to have just got dimensions to manufacture it but didn't actually try it.  I'm pretty sure there is a topic about it and I don't recall exactly what the issues are.

The only reason you should need the quick time bellhousing is if you will be racing at a level where a blow-proof bellhousing is required.  In a similar regard, if you plan to abuse it often, it might be a good idea for that extra insurance, so that you can keep your legs.
I wouldn't expect this to cause much of a problem with your crossmember as the input shaft dictates a certain dimension between the crank and transmission flange, regardless of the bellhousing used.  If it is different, it will be by a small, easily correctable amount.

The Super Duty T5 they sell appears to be the standard aftermarket T-5z, that tends to be rated anywhere from 300-330 ftlbs.  If they offer a 450ftlbs T5, then it probably is a G-Force or Astro upgrade.  Check with them all.


By FORD DEARBORN - 7 Years Ago
Not sure how things will fit together in your 37 but I'm 99% sure the steel Quick Time bell housing will not accept the standard y- block starter.  That unique sound of the starter is something I would hate to give up if I didn't have to. Good luck with your build and keep reporting,  JEFF...............
By Rono - 7 Years Ago
Thanks guys. I think I'll keep my cast iron bellhousing. The owner of this company (MDL) said he used to work for G Force Transmissions and that they didn't hold up to their supposed HP rating. The Super Duty T-5 that MDL sells has all new gears, syncro's and main shaft. I'll talk to them more and compare my parts to theirs, but I'm not really interested in re-inventing the wheel with a new, $700 steel bell housing.
By charliemccraney - 7 Years Ago
They might use Astro, then.  There can't be too many places that make T5 upgrade parts.  I think Astro produce their own beefed up case.  There is some place that does or did at one time.  Astro's case does look different than the factory case of the T5 in my truck.
By Shaggy - 7 Years Ago
Where steel bellhousings benefit is when the flywheel comes apart at 9k
By Genuinerod - 7 Years Ago
I agree with the above comments about the strength of the bell housing.  I looked into the Quick Time bell housings a few years ago and found that in order to use them on a Y Block you must also buy their redrilled FE flywheel and starter to work.  The Y Block parts will not fit.  Also to note, the TKO 5 & 6 transmissions are higher from the center line of the main shaft than the T5 and may hit the tunnel of your car.  Just saying.
By LordMrFord - 7 Years Ago
If I ever change to manual transmission, it gonna be zf gs6-53dz from BMW.
Six speed and stands a lot of abusing.
By DryLakesRacer - 7 Years Ago
I know this site doesn't speak to kindly of using of using GM stuff but what's the problem in using a Wilcap or Bendsten adapter to a GM trans and bolting up a GM bellhousing.  The starter would not be an issue as I read them but I'm sure there are other items to be addressed like the flywheel but I'm always open to any reasonable suggestion because I'm a hot rodder and that's we not only do but it's expected. Good Luck
By charliemccraney - 7 Years Ago
A bellhousing adapter would be an unnecessary expense for this task.  Adapting a manual transmission is a fairly easy task, whereas adapting an automatic, which tends to have an integral bellhousing, is not.
By Small block - 7 Years Ago
One of  my  buddy's  runs  A T5  in a Fox body mustang with a  302  the car has run a best of 11.24  at 119 mph! 
He  makes full power shifts  and he has over 400 passes on it with out a fail. He builds his own from a stock Mustang Box. 

The reasons the stock  transmission fails is because the  Cluster  support plate is stamped steal  and distorts quickly causing the  gears to become out of  mesh. To cure this  He replaces it with  solid steal  plate made by Paul Cangilosie. 
the second thing he changes is he replaces The  Aluminum input bearing  retainer   with a steal one.   The shifter fork  tabs and the slider keys  are another thing he replaces!